
Little Wicomico Oyster Company, the Virginia grower whose raw oysters CDC says made 28 people sick in 13 states, has sued the Virginia Marine Resources Commission for more than $9.1 million. According to WRIC, which reviewed the court documents, the company says the Commission and the Virginia Marine Police kept it from tending about 75 million juvenile oysters in the Little Wicomico River after the Virginia Department of Health closed the river on October 9, and that about 16 million of them died.
A disclosure first. Marler Clark represents two people sickened in this outbreak in federal lawsuits against the company: a Colorado woman in Denver and, with Regan Zambri Long, a Maryland man hospitalized with sepsis, in Richmond. I have no part in the company’s case against the Commission, and I take no position on whether Virginia owes it money. My interest is in what happens to the oysters.
The short version
- The outbreak: 28 sick, 13 states, five hospitalized, no deaths, as of CDC’s October 30 update. The investigation is open. Illnesses began as early as May 29.
- The river: closed to oyster and clam harvest since October 9, indefinitely since November 8. Four rounds of oysters from the company’s cages have been tested. All four found Salmonella.
- The lawsuit: filed Sunday, November 15, in Northumberland County Circuit Court. It asks for a permanent injunction protecting 58 million living seed oysters and payment for 16 million dead ones.
- The court order: a Lancaster County Circuit Court judge has allowed the company to pull seed oysters from the closed river, work them at its plant, and put them back.
- The open question: what those oysters will have to show before anyone eats one raw.
What the company has filed
WRIC reports that the complaint accuses the Commission and the Marine Police of unlawfully barring maintenance since about October 12, and alleges that officers threatened to arrest owner Andrew Cockrell if he took a bag or cage of seed oysters out of the water. The company’s lawyer, Tim Anderson, wrote on X that the damages claim is one for inverse condemnation. He has estimated a possible 30 percent loss, more than 20 million oysters, and posted on Monday that “these 480,000 are already dead.”
The husbandry is real work. Juvenile oysters are pulled, tumbled, broken apart, sized, rebagged and returned. 13News Now, which covered the hearing, reports that Mr. Cockrell testified the company has about 54,000 cages plus nursery bags, roughly three years of production, and that oysters were already dying in their bags.
The dates are not consistent in the reporting. 13News Now puts the hearing and the restraining order on November 6. WRIC dates the order November 12. Mr. Anderson wrote on November 13 that the Supreme Court of Virginia had rejected the state’s emergency appeal and dissolved a stay. I have not seen the orders. The next hearing is set for December 11 at 2 p.m. in Lancaster County.
As 13News Now describes the order, the company may clean, sort, resize and rebag its seed stock and return it to the river, and Marine Police may watch on the water or at the plant. The order does not reopen the river, allow sales from it, or establish that the oysters are safe to eat.
The numbers do not reconcile yet
- 75 million oysters less 58 million living is 17 million, not 16 million.
- Thirty percent of 75 million is 22.5 million.
- The only loss described as already counted is 480,000.
- $9.1 million for 16 million oysters is about 57 cents each, described as market value, for oysters that are not market size.
The complaint may explain all of this. The news reports do not.
The rule the judge relied on turns on six months
13News Now reports that the judge pointed to the Commission’s own relay regulation, 4VAC20-310-20, which says nothing in that chapter prohibits harvesting, transporting or handling seed-stock shellfish from condemned areas. The same chapter defines seed stock as shellfish “at least six months from marketing for human consumption.”
That definition is where the public health question sits. Mr. Cockrell testified, according to 13News Now, that the 75 million range from very small seed to oysters approaching market size. WRIC, describing the order, says the seed oysters are months from market size. How many months, for how many oysters, and by whose count?
Six months is a calendar, not a test. At the hearing, the Commission’s lawyer said no studies show whether seed oysters purge Salmonella in clean water, and a health department witness said the agency has no established purging rate for Salmonella and does not regulate seed stock the way it regulates market oysters. These oysters are not going to clean water in any event. The order sends them back to the same river.
What Virginia has found in that river
| Collected | What Virginia sampled | Result |
| October 13 | 400 oysters from company cages, eight meat samples, four leases | Eight of eight positive for Salmonella |
| October 21 | Company cages, four leases | Three of four leases positive |
| November 2 | Company cages, eight meat samples | Three of eight positive, two leases |
| November 9 | Company cages, ten meat samples, five leases | Ten of ten positive |
| November 16 | Fifth round | No results posted; page last updated November 17 |
Reopening takes three consecutive clean rounds, and there has not been one. Bird feces and a human sewage marker tested negative, and the health department has not identified the source. Its outbreak page, last updated November 17, says nothing about seed oysters or the court order. I laid out the third round on Food Poison Journal and CDC’s findings here.
Questions I would want answered before December 11
- How many of the 75 million oysters are at least six months from market today, and who verifies it?
- Will oysters raised in this river be tested for Salmonella before sale, or does the six-month clock alone clear them?
- Will the three-clean-rounds standard that governs the river also govern this crop?
- WRIC reports the judge found no cross-contamination risk because the seed and market operations are in separate waterways. Is the plant where seed is tumbled the same plant that handles market oysters from the company’s other rivers, and what separates the two on shore?
- Where do the dead oysters and shell go?
- Will the health department finish a purging study before any of these oysters reach market size?
A court has agreed that these oysters need tending, and a dying crop is a real loss to a family business. I do not doubt either point. But the people in this outbreak began getting sick in May, months before the September 18 to October 8 harvest that was recalled. Who pays for the dead oysters is a question for the Commission and the court. What the living ones must show before someone eats them raw is a question for everyone else.












